Client Login
N Financial Plans

Guide · Fiduciary Duty

Are All Fiduciaries Held to the Same Standard?

Legal, ERISA, credential-based, and voluntary fiduciary duties side by side: who oversees each, what a breach can cost the professional, and why that matters for your recourse. This is our own understanding, not legal advice.

Educational guide · Updated

The short answer

No. “Fiduciary” is one word covering several different obligations. Some come from federal law, such as for registered investment advisers and workplace retirement plans. Others come from a credential, state law, a trust document, or a personal pledge. The source decides who oversees the duty, what can happen if it is broken, and what recourse a client may have.

Important: what this guide is and is not

Not legal advice
N Financial Plans and the people who write for it are not a law firm and are not lawyers acting for you. Nothing in this guide is legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. It is also not personalized investment or tax advice.
This guide is our own opinion and understanding of how these rules and standards work. We are not regulators. The SEC, the Department of Labor, the CFP Board, NAPFA, and every other body mentioned here have not reviewed or endorsed it.
Laws, rules, and court decisions change and can be read in more than one way. Our summaries are simplified and may be incomplete or out of date. When a summary and a primary source differ, the primary source controls. We link the sources throughout so you can read the original text and reach your own conclusion.
Descriptions of consequences show what a rule allows. They do not predict what will happen to any person or firm, and nothing here suggests that any professional has broken any duty. For a specific situation, speak with a licensed attorney in your state.

Six kinds of fiduciary duty at a glance

Hearing that someone is a fiduciary tells you a duty exists. It does not tell you which one. The graphic below scores six common kinds against four possible consequences. Read across a row to see what that framework allows, then use the sections that follow for the detail. If you are new to the term, start with our guide to financial planner vs fiduciary.

Consequences each kind of fiduciary duty can attach to a breach
Kind of dutyCredential or membershipRegulator or agency actionCivil liabilityCriminal exposure
Federal adviser duty (Registered investment advisers)Not by itselfYesDependsYes
ERISA fiduciary (Workplace retirement plans)Not by itselfYesYesDepends
CFP Board duty (CFP® professionals giving financial advice)YesNot by itselfNot by itselfNot by itself
State and common law (Relationships a court treats as fiduciary)Not by itselfDependsYesDepends
Trustee, executor, or agent (Trusts, estates, powers of attorney)Not by itselfDependsYesDepends
Voluntary pledge (Oaths, memberships, written promises)DependsDependsDependsNot by itself
Federal adviser duty (Registered investment advisers): Credential or membership, not by itself; Regulator or agency action, yes; Civil liability, depends; Criminal exposure, yes. ERISA fiduciary (Workplace retirement plans): Credential or membership, not by itself; Regulator or agency action, yes; Civil liability, yes; Criminal exposure, depends. CFP Board duty (CFP® professionals giving financial advice): Credential or membership, yes; Regulator or agency action, not by itself; Civil liability, not by itself; Criminal exposure, not by itself. State and common law (Relationships a court treats as fiduciary): Credential or membership, not by itself; Regulator or agency action, depends; Civil liability, yes; Criminal exposure, depends. Trustee, executor, or agent (Trusts, estates, powers of attorney): Credential or membership, not by itself; Regulator or agency action, depends; Civil liability, yes; Criminal exposure, depends. Voluntary pledge (Oaths, memberships, written promises): Credential or membership, depends; Regulator or agency action, depends; Civil liability, depends; Criminal exposure, not by itself
Simplified for orientation, in our own words, and not legal advice. A professional can sit in more than one row at once, for example an adviser who is also a CFP® professional.Sources by row. Federal adviser duty: SEC, 2019 interpretation of the adviser standard of conduct; 15 U.S.C. § 80b-3 (SEC sanctions); 15 U.S.C. § 80b-17 (criminal penalties); Transamerica Mortgage Advisors v. Lewis, 444 U.S. 11 (1979). ERISA fiduciary: 29 U.S.C. § 1109 (ERISA fiduciary liability); Department of Labor, civil penalties; 18 U.S.C. § 664 (theft or embezzlement from a benefit plan). CFP Board duty: CFP Board, Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct; CFP Board, enforcement process; CFP Board, sanction guidelines. State and common law: SEC staff report on mandatory arbitration among registered advisers; FINRA, disputes with advisers that are not FINRA members. Trustee, executor, or agent: Remedies for breach of trust (one state’s enactment of Uniform Trust Code § 1001); Uniform Power of Attorney Act. Voluntary pledge: NAPFA, Fiduciary Oath and Code of Ethics; NAPFA, membership standards; 17 CFR § 275.206(4)-1 (adviser marketing rule).

Benefit: seeing the frameworks side by side may help you ask sharper questions. Limitation: squeezing six bodies of law into four columns leaves out detail, and real outcomes depend on the facts, the state, and the paperwork.

Federal adviser fiduciary duty (Investment Advisers Act)

Registered investment advisers owe clients a federal fiduciary duty with two parts: a duty of care and a duty of loyalty. In our reading of the SEC’s 2019 interpretation, the duty cannot be waived, though it applies in light of the scope the adviser and client agree on. Advisers registered with a state are overseen by state regulators instead, and the details vary by state.

Who it covers
Investment advisers registered with the SEC, and the people who work for them.
Who oversees it
The SEC, which can act through administrative proceedings or in federal court.
What can happen
The SEC may censure an adviser, limit its activities, suspend or revoke its registration, bar or suspend individuals, order it to stop a practice, and impose civil penalties (§ 80b-3). In court it may seek injunctions and disgorgement (§ 80b-9). Willful violations can also be prosecuted, with a statutory maximum of five years in prison (§ 80b-17).
Worst case for the professional
Being barred from the industry, paying penalties, and, if the conduct was willful and prosecuted, prison. These are the outer limits of what the statute allows, not a typical outcome.
What it may mean for you

A regulator’s action addresses the adviser. It does not automatically return money to a client.

In Transamerica Mortgage Advisors v. Lewis, the Supreme Court held that the Act’s antifraud section does not give clients a general right to sue for damages. A client may seek to void an advisory contract. Damage claims often have to rest on state law or on arbitration under the advisory agreement.

ERISA fiduciary (workplace retirement plans)

ERISA governs most private-sector workplace retirement plans, such as 401(k) plans and pensions. Under ERISA, fiduciary status follows what a person does. People with discretionary control over a plan or its assets are fiduciaries, and so is someone who gives investment advice for a fee and meets the Department of Labor’s five-part test. IRAs are treated differently, under related tax-code rules.

One current note: the Department of Labor’s 2024 attempt to widen that definition was vacated by federal courts in March 2026, and the 1975 five-part test is the operative rule as of this writing (Federal Register notice, Department of Labor). Rules in this area move, so confirm the current status before relying on it.

Who it covers
Business owners and committee members who run a workplace plan, trustees, and advisers or managers who meet ERISA’s definition.
Who oversees it
The Department of Labor’s Employee Benefits Security Administration, and federal courts.
What can happen
A fiduciary who breaches ERISA duties is personally liable to make good the plan’s losses and restore any profits made through the plan’s assets (29 U.S.C. § 1109), and a court can remove the fiduciary. In some cases the Department of Labor must also assess a civil penalty tied to the amount recovered (Department of Labor). Separately, theft or embezzlement of plan assets is a federal crime with a maximum of five years in prison (18 U.S.C. § 664). A breach alone does not necessarily establish that crime.
Worst case for the professional
Repaying plan losses from personal assets, removal from the role, and, where the conduct is theft or embezzlement, prosecution.
What it may mean for you

A participant can sue on the plan’s behalf, including for losses that fall only on the participant’s own account in a defined contribution plan (LaRue). Any recovery goes to the plan, not as a direct payment to the person.

Deadlines are short enough to matter: generally the earlier of six years after the breach or three years after the plaintiff actually knew of it (29 U.S.C. § 1113, Sulyma).

For business owners: if you sponsor a plan for your own company, you may carry these duties personally. See our guides to defined benefit plans for business owners and small business 401(k) plans. They describe plan types and trade-offs. They do not replace advice from an ERISA attorney.

CFP Board fiduciary duty (credential-based)

The CFP Board’s Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct requires CFP® professionals to act as a fiduciary, in the client’s best interests, at all times when providing financial advice. The duty has three parts: loyalty, care, and following client instructions. It is a condition of holding the certification, so it follows the person, not the firm or the type of account.

Who it covers
CFP® professionals, whenever they provide financial advice.
Who oversees it
The CFP Board, a private professional organization. Its enforcement process includes an investigation by enforcement counsel, review by a disciplinary commission, a hearing if requested, and an internal appeal. The Board must show a violation by a preponderance of the evidence.
What can happen
Private censure, public censure, suspension or revocation of the right to use the CFP® marks, and a bar on obtaining certification. Orders may also require continuing education or other undertakings (sanction guidelines).
Worst case for the professional
Permanent loss of the certification and a public disciplinary record. The Board is not a court or a government agency, so it cannot impose prison, and its listed sanctions concern the certification and do not include awarding damages to a client.
What it may mean for you

A complaint to the CFP Board can lead to discipline of the individual. It is not a way to recover money, and the duty is a professional standard rather than a statute.

Many CFP® professionals are also subject to a legal duty through their registration, which is a separate source of obligation. You can check status and public discipline with the CFP Board’s lookup tool.

State and common-law fiduciary duty

Apart from any statute or credential, state courts can treat a relationship as fiduciary when one person relies on another’s judgment, such as a client relying on an adviser. Whether a duty exists, and what it requires, depends on the state, the agreement, and the services actually provided. A label in a contract does not settle the question. State law varies, and this is the area where you most need a lawyer in your own state.

Who it covers
Anyone a court finds to be in a fiduciary relationship, which can include advisers and others who handle another person’s money or decisions.
Who oversees it
State courts, or an arbitrator if the agreement requires arbitration. State securities regulators separately oversee advisers and brokers under state securities law.
What can happen
Depending on the state and the facts: compensatory damages, disgorgement or fee forfeiture, rescission of a tainted transaction, an accounting, a constructive trust, an injunction, and punitive damages where state law allows them.
Worst case for the professional
A personal money judgment or award, which can include return of fees. Criminal exposure comes from other laws, such as fraud or theft, and not from a breach of fiduciary duty alone.
What it may mean for you

This is often the most direct private route to damages, but it comes with limits: deadlines that vary by state, the need to show loss caused by the breach, and possibly an arbitration clause.

An SEC staff report estimated that roughly 61 percent of SEC-registered advisers serving retail clients put mandatory arbitration clauses in their advisory agreements. FINRA explains how it handles disputes with advisers that are not FINRA members.

Trustees, executors, and agents under a power of attorney

These people are fiduciaries because a document or a court appointment puts them in charge of someone else’s property: a trustee under a trust, an executor of an estate, or an agent under a power of attorney. The duty matters for your own planning too, because you may be naming a family member, a professional, or an adviser to one of these roles. Our estate planning guide covers the basics. N Financial Plans is not a law firm and does not draft legal documents.

Who it covers
Trustees, executors and other personal representatives, and agents acting under a power of attorney.
Who oversees it
State courts. Beneficiaries, principals, or people acting for them can ask a court to review a fiduciary’s conduct. Rules vary by state.
What can happen
Under the Uniform Trust Code model, a court may compel a trustee to perform, stop a threatened breach, order the trustee to pay money or restore property, suspend or remove the trustee, and reduce or deny compensation (see one state’s enactment). The uniform power of attorney model makes an agent who violates it liable to restore the value of the principal’s property. States enact their own versions.
Worst case for the professional
Removal, repaying losses from personal assets, and criminal charges if the conduct amounts to theft or fraud under separate law.
What it may mean for you
The route is usually through a state court, and timing and procedure vary. A beneficiary or principal who has a concern generally benefits from speaking with an estate or trust attorney early.
Primary sources

Remedies for breach of trust (one state’s enactment of Uniform Trust Code § 1001); Uniform Power of Attorney Act

Our own understanding and not legal advice. If this summary and a source differ, the source controls.

Voluntary and membership-based fiduciary commitments

Some professionals commit to fiduciary conduct through a membership pledge, an oath, or a sentence in their marketing or agreement, without a statute or credential behind it. A well-known example is the Fiduciary Oath that NAPFA members sign. Whether a promise like this carries weight depends on where it appears and who can enforce it.

Who it covers
Anyone who makes the promise.
Who oversees it
It depends. A membership organization may enforce its own pledge. For example, NAPFA says members must keep meeting its membership standards to remain in good standing. A written promise in an advisory agreement may be enforceable as a contract. For SEC-registered advisers, the marketing rule bars advertisements that include an untrue statement of a material fact.
What can happen
Loss of a membership, a contract claim if the promise is in the agreement, or regulatory action if a statement was untrue or misleading.
Worst case for the professional
Removal from the organization and, where a claim was false or misleading, regulatory consequences.
What it may mean for you
A promise that appears only in a brochure or on a website may be hard to enforce. Ask for the commitment in your advisory agreement, in writing.
Primary sources

NAPFA, Fiduciary Oath and Code of Ethics; NAPFA, membership standards; NAPFA, fiduciary standard; 17 CFR § 275.206(4)-1 (adviser marketing rule)

Our own understanding and not legal advice. If this summary and a source differ, the source controls.

A nearby standard that is not a fiduciary duty

Brokers who sell securities are generally held to Regulation Best Interest when they recommend a securities transaction or strategy to a retail customer. SEC materials describe it and the adviser fiduciary duty as similar in important ways, and they also say it is a separate standard. It has four obligations (disclosure, care, conflicts, and compliance) rather than two duties, and it generally does not by itself require ongoing monitoring of an account.

Disputes with brokers commonly go to the arbitration forum run by FINRA, the industry’s self-regulatory organization. Some professionals are both brokers and advisers, so which standard applies can depend on the capacity in which they are acting. Ask, and ask for the answer in writing.

Sources for this section: SEC staff bulletin on care obligations; SEC, press release on Regulation Best Interest (2019); FINRA, disputes with advisers that are not FINRA membersOur own understanding and not legal advice. If this summary and a source differ, the source controls.

Why the source of the duty changes your recourse

The kind of duty decides where a concern can be raised and whether you have a claim of your own. Regulators and credentialing bodies generally address the professional. Courts and arbitrators are the usual place to seek money for your own loss. This is our general understanding, and your own facts and state law may change the answer.

Kind of dutyWhere to raise a concernA claim for your own lossWatch forPrimary sources
Federal adviser dutyThe SEC, or the state regulator for state-registered advisersLimited under the federal Act. Often a state-law claim or arbitration.An arbitration clause in the advisory agreement. Regulator action may not return money.SEC, 2019 interpretation of the adviser standard of conduct; 15 U.S.C. § 80b-9 (court actions); Transamerica Mortgage Advisors v. Lewis, 444 U.S. 11 (1979); SEC staff report on mandatory arbitration among registered advisers
ERISA fiduciaryThe plan administrator and the Department of LaborClaims are brought for the plan, and recovery goes to the plan.Deadlines tied to six years from the breach or three years from actual knowledge.29 U.S.C. § 1109 (ERISA fiduciary liability); LaRue v. DeWolff, Boberg & Associates, 552 U.S. 248 (2008); 29 U.S.C. § 1113 (ERISA deadlines); Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee v. Sulyma (2020)
CFP Board dutyThe CFP BoardNot through the Board.Discipline concerns the certification, not payment to you.CFP Board, enforcement process; CFP Board, sanction guidelines; CFP Board, verify a CFP® professional
State and common lawState courts or arbitration. The state securities regulator for conduct it oversees.Yes, depending on state law and the facts.Deadlines vary by state. You generally need to show loss caused by the breach.SEC staff report on mandatory arbitration among registered advisers; FINRA, disputes with advisers that are not FINRA members
Trustee, executor, or agentThe state court that supervises the trust or estateThrough the court, which can order repayment or restoration.Procedure and timing vary by state.Remedies for breach of trust (one state’s enactment of Uniform Trust Code § 1001); Uniform Power of Attorney Act
Voluntary pledgeThe membership organization, or the other party to a contractA contract claim is possible if the promise is in the agreement.A promise made only in marketing may be hard to enforce.NAPFA, Fiduciary Oath and Code of Ethics; NAPFA, membership standards; 17 CFR § 275.206(4)-1 (adviser marketing rule)

Benefit: knowing which row applies tells you which door to knock on first. Limitation: a stronger consequence on paper is not the same as a better chance of recovery. Many matters never reach the harshest consequence, and none of these frameworks guarantees a result.

Hypothetical, for illustration only. A client learns that an adviser did not clearly disclose a conflict of interest on a recommendation. Depending on the facts, the client might report it to the regulator, check whether the advisory agreement requires arbitration, ask whether the adviser is also a CFP® professional, and speak with an attorney about deadlines and state-law claims. Each route has a different aim, and outcomes vary.

Questions that bring the right answer to the surface

  1. Which fiduciary standards apply to you, and is it the same for every service you provide me?
  2. Will you put your fiduciary commitment in writing, in my agreement?
  3. Who oversees you, and where can I read your record? (The SEC’s adviser search at adviserinfo.sec.gov and the CFP Board’s lookup tool are two starting points.)
  4. Does your agreement require arbitration, or limit the claims I can bring or the damages I can seek?
  5. If you also act as a broker or are paid in more than one way, when do you act under which standard?

For the warning signs that sit alongside these questions, see our guide to advisor red flags.

Which of these apply to N Financial Plans and to us

You should know which duties we say apply to us and how to check them yourself. N Financial Plans is a fee-only, fiduciary firm. We accept zero commissions and sell no products. The table below is our own description. Please verify each item at the linked source, and read our Form ADV Part 2A, Part 2B, and Form CRS on our compliance page, which describe our services, fees, and conflicts.

Source of the dutyHow it applies to usWho can oversee or disciplineVerify it yourself
SEC-registered investment adviser (federal fiduciary duty)Long Island Financial LLC, doing business as N Financial Plans, states in its Form CRS that it is registered with the SEC as an investment adviser. The federal adviser duty applies to the advice we give clients.The SEC.SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure record for N Financial Plans; SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure record for our founder; N Financial Plans Form CRS; SEC, 2019 interpretation of the adviser standard of conduct; 15 U.S.C. § 80b-3 (SEC sanctions)
CFP Board fiduciary dutyOur founder holds the CFP® certification, so the CFP Board’s standard applies to the financial advice they give.The CFP Board, through discipline of the certification.CFP Board, verify a CFP® professional; CFP Board, Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct; CFP Board, enforcement process; CFP Board, sanction guidelines
NAPFA Fiduciary Oath and fee-only standards (membership commitment)NAPFA’s public directory lists N Financial Plans, and shows our founder as a NAPFA-Registered Financial Advisor. NAPFA members commit to its Fiduciary Oath, Code of Ethics, and Fee-Only standards. This is a membership commitment, not a law.NAPFA, through membership consequences under its own standards and bylaws.NAPFA directory listing for N Financial Plans; NAPFA, Fiduciary Oath and Code of Ethics; NAPFA, membership standards; NAPFA, fiduciary standard
ERISA fiduciary dutyWhether we act as an ERISA fiduciary for a particular retirement plan depends on the role we take in that engagement. We do not assume it applies, and you can ask us to state our role in writing.The Department of Labor and federal courts.29 U.S.C. § 1109 (ERISA fiduciary liability); Federal Register, March 20, 2026 (vacatur of the 2024 rule); Department of Labor announcement, March 18, 2026
State and common lawThese can apply to client relationships in addition to the sources above, and the rules depend on the state. Our office is in New York. We cannot tell you how a court would treat any particular situation.State courts, arbitrators, and state securities regulators.SEC staff report on mandatory arbitration among registered advisers; FINRA, disputes with advisers that are not FINRA members
IRS Enrolled Agent rules (Circular 230)Our founder is also an IRS Enrolled Agent. Circular 230 sets conduct rules for practice before the IRS. It is a professional conduct regime for tax practice, and we do not describe it as a fiduciary duty.The IRS Office of Professional Responsibility.31 CFR § 10.50 (Circular 230 sanctions); IRS, Office of Professional Responsibility and Circular 230

Benefit: more than one body can look at the same advice, so a concern has more than one place to be raised. Limitation: overlapping oversight does not mean any of it is certain to catch a problem, and it does not promise results or make any firm free of conflicts. SEC registration, CFP® certification, and NAPFA membership are not endorsements and do not imply a certain level of skill or training. Fee-only means we are paid by clients, and it is a different question from which duties apply.

For a neutral look at your current arrangement, a complimentary second opinion is a review, not a transfer, and you decide what happens next. We are not a law firm, so for a dispute or a legal question, speak with an attorney.

Primary sources and as-of dates

Law and regulation change. Everything below was reviewed on November 20, 2026. These are the primary sources behind this guide. We repeat them throughout the page on purpose. Confirm current rules at the source before you act, and treat the source, not our summary, as the authority.

Investment Advisers Act and the SEC

ERISA and the Department of Labor

CFP Board, NAPFA, and the IRS

State law, trusts, and powers of attorney

Our own disclosures

Disclaimer

Please read
This guide is for general education only. It is our own opinion and understanding of the regulations and standards discussed, written by people who are not attorneys and not regulators. N Financial Plans is not a law firm. Nothing here is legal advice, tax advice, or personalized investment advice, and nothing here creates an attorney-client relationship or an advisory relationship.
We have tried to describe each source accurately and to link the primary text, but we cannot promise that our summaries are complete, current, or free of error. No regulator, credentialing body, or membership organization named here has reviewed or approved this page. Descriptions of penalties and remedies show what a rule permits and do not predict outcomes. They do not suggest that any person or firm has violated any duty.
Past, current, and future rules may differ from what is described, and the right answer for you depends on your facts and your state. Before acting on anything here, speak with a licensed attorney. SEC registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Investing involves risk, including the potential loss of principal.

Frequently asked questions

In our understanding, common kinds include the federal duty of registered investment advisers, ERISA fiduciaries for workplace retirement plans, the CFP Board’s duty for CFP® professionals, duties that arise under state and common law, fiduciaries named in trusts, estates, and powers of attorney, and voluntary commitments such as a membership oath. They differ in who oversees them and what can happen if one is broken. See the primary sources linked above, and speak with an attorney about your own situation.

A fiduciary breach on its own is generally a civil or regulatory matter. Willful violations of the Investment Advisers Act can be prosecuted (15 U.S.C. § 80b-17), and theft or embezzlement of ERISA plan assets is a federal crime (18 U.S.C. § 664). Conduct such as fraud or theft can also be prosecuted under separate laws whatever fiduciary label applies. The CFP Board is a private body and cannot bring criminal charges. This is general education and not legal advice.

Sometimes. The Supreme Court held in Transamerica Mortgage Advisors v. Lewis that the federal Investment Advisers Act does not give clients a general right to sue for damages, so claims often rest on state law, and many advisory agreements require arbitration (SEC staff report). Deadlines vary. We are not a law firm. A lawyer experienced in investment disputes can tell you what applies to your facts.

No. It is a professional standard that CFP® professionals agree to as a condition of certification, and the CFP Board enforces it by disciplining the credential (enforcement process). Many CFP® professionals are also subject to a legal fiduciary duty through their registration, which is a separate source of obligation.

Regulation Best Interest requires broker-dealers to act in a retail customer’s best interest when they make recommendations, but SEC materials treat it as a separate standard from the adviser fiduciary duty (SEC staff bulletin). Some professionals are both brokers and advisers, so ask which standard applies to each service.

Let’s Talk It Through

Questions About Your Own Situation?

Schedule a complimentary conversation with our Certified Financial Planners® and IRS Enrolled Agents. Please fill out the form, or call to get started.

Monday to Friday 9:30AM – 4 PM

By Appointment Only (But, if the stock market is open, we’re open.)

179 New York Avenue, 2nd Floor
Huntington, NY 11743